East Palo Alto Bay Trail Will Be Built. Will Current Residents Benefit From It?

Ravenswood Bay Trail Map
The missing 0.6-mile segment of San Francisco Bay Trail through East Palo Alto requires crossing SFPUC property and protected wetlands. Image: Midpeninsula Regional Open Space District

The pieces are in place to build a key link in the San Francisco Bay Trail, providing a continuous bike route through East Palo Alto and Menlo Park. Given the trail’s proximity to Facebook and the lack of housing close to the company’s campus, East Palo is also looking to strengthen its affordable housing policies to ensure that current residents can afford to stay in the city and benefit from the new path.

Local officials from five different agencies met on Monday to iron out the details of an agreement that fully funds the San Francisco Bay Trail through East Palo Alto, filling in the 100-mile network of off-street trails connecting Redwood City and Union City with downtown San Jose, Mountain View, and central Santa Clara.

“This is one of the most difficult gaps in the Bay Trail to complete,” said San Mateo County Parks Director Marlene Finley, whose department will manage funds for the project. “It’s wonderful that all the project partners are able to come together and get this done.”

The missing section lies within both East Palo Alto and Menlo Park, and is subject to a number of regulatory agencies where the trail will cross protected wetlands in the Ravenswood Open Space Preserve. The multi-jurisdictional nature of the project and complex political environment has delayed it for decades while every other section of the San Francisco Bay Trail in the mid-Peninsula region has been built or improved. The network of continuous off-street trails now stretches nearly from the Union City BART Station to downtown San Jose, except for this remaining gap.

Sam Felder Ghost Bike
Sam Felder was struck by a driver on Marsh Road near the SF Bay Trail on his way to work at Facebook, sustaining injuries that ended his life five months later. Photo: Andrew Boone

“As someone who regularly leads bicycle commuting rides through this area, the completion of the missing Bay Trail segment in East Palo Alto will be a big boost to recreational and commuter bicyclists,” said SF2G Bicycle Commuting Club co-founder Brett Lider. “This increased bike traffic makes it even more important to fix the hazardous intersections along Bayfront Expressway in Menlo Park that lead to to the new path, especially at Marsh Road, Willow Road, and University Avenue.”

The project, lacking funds, remained dormant after a feasibility study was published by Menlo Park in 2005 [PDF]. Facebook’s relocation in 2012 to the former Sun Microsystems campus just west of the missing trail section finally provided a catalyst, with Menlo Park requiring the social media giant to build a half-mile section of the trail lying within its own borders along University Avenue as a condition of development. The remaining half-mile of trail in East Palo Alto was excluded from the agreement, however, and Facebook declined to fund it, offering instead to work with other large employers to seek private or public monies for its completion.

“We have been longtime supporters of the Ravenswood Bay Trail Connection Project,” wrote Facebook Vice-President of Global Real Estate and Facilities John Tenanes in a statement yesterday. “Facebook has actively supported the Association of Bay Area Governments and the Midpeninsula Regional Open Space District in their quest to secure the necessary funding to complete the trail, and is pleased the project will move forward soon.”

“Once the trail is finished, it will be a great resource for residents and visitors, and will enable an easier commute for anyone who currently bikes or plans to bike to work,” said Tenanes.

This March, San Mateo County allocated the final $1 million of $2.1 million needed to build the trail, using funds from its 2012 Measure A. Santa Clara County and funds from the Mid-peninsula Regional Open Space District’s 2014 Measure AA are the other sources of funds.

SF Bay Trail Along University Avenue in Menlo Park
A new section of Bay Trail constructed by Facebook in April completes the trail through Menlo Park, but stops here at the city’s border with East Palo Alto. There is currently no trail or sidewalk south of this point. Photo: Andrew Boone

Environmental review is expected to be finished by late 2015 or early 2016, and construction should wrap in 2017. The project has yet to secure the necessary permits, including an easement from the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC), and approval from the state’s Fish and Wildlife Department and other regulatory agencies.

“Linking  the two Internet hubs — Facebook and Mountain View’s North Bayshore tech area — the Bay Trail could help address some of the area’s congestion problems,” said East Palo Alto City Council Member Carlos Romero in a statement yesterday. “The trail’s proximity to Palo Alto and Menlo Park may prompt employees of tech firms to bike this scenic route to work, and East Palo Alto may become more attractive to well-heeled tech workers wishing to locate closer to work, thereby bidding up the city’s housing costs.”

East Palo Alto strongly supports the Bay Trail completion project, citing its role in improving the health and mobility of residents in its General Plan and Bay Access Master Plan [PDF]. As housing costs soar in East Palo Alto and the region amidst Silicon Valley’s economic boom, the city is also pursuing a number of anti-displacement measures [PDF].

“Unfortunately, few East Palo Alto residents are directly employed by these firms, and I would not want to see our residents burdened by an amenity that others see as a benefit,” said Romero. “This is why in addition to bike and ped transportation improvements, we need strong housing protections for local low-income residents.”

  • djconnel

    Yesterday I rode the newly refurbished tunnel (it existed for a long time but was closed to accrss) under the expressway immediately opposite Facebook. Wow — very nice! Nice except it was so packed with Facebook employees, walking many-abreast, as well as cyclists that it was slow-going. The one issue with the tunnel is if you use it and are going north-south you still need to go through a busy intersection to cross Willow with very long light cycles. But it’s a big improvement and although I have no problem riding through East Palo Alto residential streets, which have very low traffic, I really look forward to the Bay Trail extension. Providing key bicycle connectivity should be treated as seriously as car connectivity and few would argue that major north-south car routes should be truncated to reduce housing values.

  • saimin

    Really whiny title to this article. Not everyone will use every trail, but a good trail network as a whole will benefit all users.

  • shotwellian

    It’s worth pointing out that there are other trail gaps in the area. North of here, three miles of the “trail” heading toward Redwood City are highway frontage roads, mostly lacking sidewalks, through industrial areas. Some of the route through Newark and Fremont is also along wide, industrial roads. Not terrible as bike routes, but clearly not a trail in any real sense.

  • saimin

    The Bay Trail sections in Redwood City have bike lanes, so they are semi-tolerable at least for bicyclists. The routes are pretty ugly, so pedestrians probably won’t want to bother.

    The East Bay routes through Newark and Fremont mostly have no bike lanes and have heavy traffic on weekdays, as well as being not especially scenic. I wouldn’t recommend these to anyone.

  • shotwellian

    I agree that the Redwood City sections are not bad as bike routes, but my point is that industrial highway frontage roads, even with bike lanes, shouldn’t be counted as completed Bay Trail, and therefore there are more gaps in the Bay Trail than there appear to be.

  • Reid

    No bike lane past the Porsche dealer in Menlo Park, between Marsh and the trailer park in Redwood City.
    No bike lane as the road narrows towards Seaport.
    No bike lane through Docktown Marina, past the homeless encampment under 101, over the bridge, past the VW dealer.


Momentum Builds to Eliminate Dangerous Gap in SF Bay Trail

Prospects for a safer and more convenient San Francisco Bay Trail are looking brighter as momentum builds for strengthening environmental protections along the bay in San Mateo County. On Tuesday, Menlo Park planning staff reported that the city, in partnership with neighboring East Palo Alto and Palo Alto, as well as the Midpeninsula Regional Open […]

Eyes on the Street: East Palo Alto’s First Sharrows

When East Palo Alto repaved Woodland Avenue between Newell Avenue and West Bayshore Road in late March, one half-mile of the city’s bumpiest pothole-filled street was suddenly transformed into its smoothest one, complete with new striping and well-placed sharrows on top. City planners hope the sharrows will help residents bike and drive more predictably on Woodland’s […]

East Palo Alto’s Highway 101 Ped/Bike Bridge Almost Fully Funded

East Palo Alto’s decades-long dream to reconnect its east and west sides via a pedestrian/bicycle bridge has taken a huge leap forward. The California Department of Transportation (Caltrans) approved the city’s $8.6 million application to construct a 12-foot wide bridge over Highway 101 between Newell Road and Clarke Avenue, following East Palo Alto’s City Council’s […]